12.12.2005

Modern Ruins

History is littered with civilizations that failed. Failed for many reasons, political, environmental, etc. They exist throughout the world in all manner of geographies and climates, though they do tend to be concentrated within a narrow range north and south of the equator (at least in my understanding of them).

Some highlights:

Angkor Wat - Cambodia
Way more impressive than I ever realized - recent satellite studies have shown this complex to be unbelievably vast. Most likely failed as a result of exceeding the capability of their environment to support them, coupled with other political and disease factors.


Pompeii - Italy

Everybody knows the story on this one. Vesuvius erupts and takes out Pompeii and another nearby city Herculaneum.









Copan - Honduras

Copan is one of dozens of sites in Central America once part of the Mayan civilization. While descendants of the Maya still exist, nothing remains of their civilization but ruins, many of which remained swallowed by the jungle.










All of these ruins were part of civilizations that existed for hundreds, if not thousands of years. They probably seemed generally invincible to those that lived there, but they still failed. Other than the possible dissolution of our civilization (meaning The United States) and absorption into a larger world culture, are they places that we could look to as likely ruins?

Travel through the west and you'll find plenty of old mining towns. The town of Centralia Pennsylvania has a fascinating history, and a remarkable demise. The old mining towns were rarely more than a collection of enterprising people who knew that their time was limited, but Centralia fits remarkably well into this idea of modern ruin.

Is New Orleans destined to become either a modern ruin, or some quaint museum piece. Is it reasonable to rebuild a place so tenuously holding its place in the world against the overwhelming force of mother nature.

What about Phoenix? Or Las Vegas. Two places that have no business being so large in places with so little water. Can they possibly last another 100 years?

The town of Chelsea, in Iowa, was regularly the victim of flooding, and after the floods of 1993, decided collectively to relocate to higher ground. But Chelsea is a tiny place with only a handful of residents. Could you imagine moving New Orleans? Would it still be New Orleans?

It seems to me that we, as a society are blind to the realities of time. We assume that what we know will always be there, even though it may change over time, we simply don't consider the fact that it could go away altogether. Look at the satellite photos from the tsunami in Indonesia. These places are forever changed. The no longer look anything like they did before, but they maintained continuity. It doesn't always work that way, and that is a thought worth considering.

10 comments:

Dan said...

Interesting (& spooky) line of thought! You speak with logic. There's much study in sociology & geography over the demise of small-town America. Also, Prayre Erth talk a lot of early white settlements or homesteads that were built in places that weren't capable of withstanding what Kansas threw at them in the early to mid 1880s. But we, as a society, have not allowed ourselves to delve into the topic of our major cities & institutions failing; though we GISers have a community, at least, dedicated to disaster modeling & forecasting. I'm sure other industries have their various horn-blowers running about that are perceived of as Chicken Littles by a greater society that doesn't even want to go there. The concept of re-building New Orleans seems like a big ol' Ego Trip for the US of A.

For huge civilizations that existed for hundreds of years-a couple that could be thrown in is China-Ming Dynasty & so on, that I don't know very much about, but also Egypt (which I was just reading about last night) which had an astonishing 30 dynasties, being politically, economically, and militarily dominant from pre-3000 BC to about 700 BC. It's freaking amazing, if you think about it.

It was interesting, with the Egyptian dynasties, as I read about the Old Kingdom and the New Kingdom & how various leaders had their respective reaches extended & curtailed during their reigns, depending on their relative successes, influence, & strategy. The parallels with Nuemenor were astonishing (I wouldn't be surprised if he used that region as an influence-especially with the line of kings with the "Tar" title). Of course, everything ties back to Lord of the Rings...

Pat said...

Romans would be another principal reference for Numenor, particularly the period known as the Pax Romana (Roman Peace). Rome's reach was felt throughout most of Europe and Amon Sul's and Isengards are all over.

They also experienced various ebbs and flows, though when they finally went, they went with a bang. Rome went from a city of one million to a city of 12,000 in a remarkably short time. The people that stayed burned marble to get lime. Pretty much as low as they could go. And it all happened because of political corruption, mostly, and a little thing called Christianity.

C.F. Bear said...

To lighten the talk a wee bit, I went to the Cedar Falls City Council and asked them to build a Helms Deep refuge center incase we are attacked by Waterloonians. They are concidering the idea and will take the thought to heart. Imagine CF being a modern ruin because of a vast war between neighbors. Could it happen? I hope to not find out.

Pat said...

Is there a force of evil strong enough in Waterloo to bind together the loose tribes and thugs into a cohesive force potent enough to assail the heights of Cedar Falls? If there his, his or her identity remains shrouded in mystery.

C.F. Bear said...

It is the fourth, fifth, sixth, seventh, and eigth graders in the schools. They will break lose the prisioners and round up the meth heads and they will run to CF with the bones of teachers, Suedafed boxes filled with rocks, and rolled up posters of naked girls to beat us with. Watch out! Thank goodness I teach younger kids.

Pat said...

Cedar Falls should not fear a disorganized uprising such as you describe. Without a leader all you'll get is mayhem, and no real threat.

C.F. Bear said...

Don't under estimate the power of the dark side.

Dan said...

Well, if it ends up a group of kids that assails you, that'll be the matchup you've been dreaming about for years.

C.F. Bear said...

It would be similar to the battles on Narnia and in TLOTRs.

Pat said...

Except with a bunch of badly winded teens on one side, and a bunch of upwardly mobile white people on the other.